School Refusal

Etiology

It is difficult to determine the number of children that experience school refusal. A common statistic cited by organizations that advocate for increased mental health awareness suggests school refusal affects 2% to 5% of all school-age children. If the child has been home for a while, for example during summer vacation, another holiday break, or a brief illness, it may trigger the problem. A stressful event like the death of a pet or relative or moving to a new house may also precipitate the condition. When a child does not want to go to school often says they are sick. When they wake up in the morning, they complain of having a headache, stomachache, or a sore throat. If someone allows them to stay home, the “illness” might go away, but it comes back the next morning before school. Some children may have crying spells or temper tantrums.[3][4]

Epidemiology

Fear of going to school was first called "school phobia" in 1941. Approximately 2% to 5% of all school-aged children experience school refusal. The incidence is similar between boys and girls. Although school refusal occurs at all ages, it is more common in children ages 5 to 6 and 10 to 11 years of age. The longer a child is out of school, the harder it is to return. No socioeconomic differences have been noted.[4]

History and Physical

Refusal to attend school was not a stand-alone clinical entity, but instead, it can be a manifestation of an underlying affective or behavioral disorder defined in the DSM-5. Apprehensive school refusal and truancy are symptoms, rather than distinct diagnoses.[4][5]

Diagnosis often depends on history. Physical examinations are generally unremarkable. 

Evaluation

It is difficult to determine how many students miss school due to anxiety because many parents cover for their kids. Parents call the school to say that their child is sick, especially parents whose child's symptom of anxiety manifests physically in the form of a headache or stomach pain. Stressful events may lead to school refusal. Some children head to school in the morning and become anxious as they get closer to school; then they cannot proceed. Other children refuse to go to school at all. Their presenting symptoms include fearfulness, panic symptoms, crying episodes, temper tantrums, threats of self-harm, and somatic symptoms that present in the morning and improve when the child stays home.[4][5]

Symptoms

Autonomic: Muscular, dizziness, abdominal pain, back pain, diaphoresis, joint pain, headaches, shakiness/trembling, palpitations, chest pains

Gastrointestinal (GI): Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea

Stressful life events like moving or starting a new school, among others may trigger School Refusal. Other reasons include the child’s fear a parent being harmed once they are in school or fear that they may not do well in school, or they may be afraid of another student.[3]

Treatment / Management

A range of empirically supported exposure-based treatment options is available in the management of school refusal. Treatments include cognitive behavior therapy, educational-support therapy, pharmacotherapy, and sometimes parent-teacher interventions. Providers may provide psychoeducational support for the child and parents, monitor medications, and help with a referral to more intensive psychotherapy. A younger child may display minor symptoms of fear, anxiety, and depression and may work directly with parents, the school personnel may help the child get over their fears, and there may not be a need for other intervention. Child therapy with parents and school staff may be indicated if the child's difficulties include comorbid psychiatric diagnosis, prolonged school absence, or deficits in social skills. Behavior treatments include relaxation training, systematic desensitization (that is graded exposure to the school environment), emotive imagery, social skills training, and contingency management. Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) is a very structured strategy where a therapist offers specific instructions for children to enable and gradually increase their exposure to the school environment. In CBT, children are encouraged to confront their fears, and they are taught how to modify negative thoughts.

The provider may choose to focus on a psychologist who practices CBT. CBT provides solutions to current problems and provides tools to change unhelpful thoughts and behaviors. The treating physician may also consider a therapist who is trained in exposure-response therapy (ERP). ERP focuses on gradual exposures to anxiety-inducing stimuli and situations. It is usually performed in the most anxiety-producing situations so that the individual can confidently proceed in the therapy. Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) is also effective in treating anxiety and school refusal. It is based on 4 skill modules which include 2 sets of acceptance-oriented skills (mindfulness and distress tolerance) and 2 sets of change-oriented skills (emotion regulation and interpersonal effectiveness). Treatment addresses comorbid psychiatric problems, family dysfunction, and other contributing problems. If a child who refuses to go to school has presented with physical symptoms, the physician should explain that signs of physical illnesses are the manifestation of psychological distress rather than a physical illness. A collaborative team approach with multimodal facilities which include the physician, child, parents, school staff, and other mental health professionals should be applied. Physicians should avoid writing a non-judicial excuse note for children to stay out of school unless a medical condition makes it mandatory for them to stay home.

Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) have replaced tricyclic antidepressants as the first-line pharmacologic treatment for anxiety disorders in children. Although there are few controlled, double-blind studies of SSRI use in children; the data suggest that SSRIs are effective and safe in the treatment of childhood anxiety disorders. Clinically, SSRIs are used frequently used to treat school refusal. Sertraline can be started at an initial dose of 12.5 to 25 mg per day for a minimum of 7 days and titrated up to 50 mg per day in increments of 12.5 mg (child) or 25 to 50 mg (adolescent) per week. If adequate clinical response is not seen after 6 to 8 weeks of treatment, subsequent trials should be tried following dose increases of 12.5 mg per day for children and 25 to 50 mg per day for adolescents to a maximum of 200 mg per day.

Benzodiazepines can be used on a short-term basis for children with severe school refusal. Benzodiazepine may be added with an SSRI to target acute symptoms of anxiety. It should be discontinued once the SSRI has had time to produce beneficial effects as there is a risk for addiction and side effects. There are many side effects of benzodiazepines such as sedation, behavior disinhibition, crankiness, and cognitive impairment that should keep in mind. Clonazepam can be started at 0.25 mg per day. The dose can then be increased to 0.5 mg per day if well-tolerated; further increases are based on response and tolerability. Lorazepam can be started at 0.25 mg per day. Maintenance daily dose can be increased to 8 mg per day if well-tolerated. Because of the side effects and risk of dependence, benzodiazepines, if used, should be used for only a few weeks.[1][4][2](B3)

Differential Diagnosis

Differential Diagnosis Criteria for School Refusal and Truancy

School Refusal

1. Severe emotional distress about attending school manifests as anxiety, temper tantrums, depression, or somatic symptoms
2. Parents are aware of absence; the child often tries to persuade parents to allow him or her to stay home
3. Antisocial behaviors such as juvenile delinquency are not notably seen
4. Children usually stay home during school hours

Truancy

1. Excessive anxiety or fear about attending school are not commonly seen; rather child often tries to conceal absence from parents
2. Antisocial behavior such as delinquent and disruptive acts, for example, lying and stealing, are frequent in the company of antisocial peers.
3. The child frequently does not stay home during school hours.
4. Anxious school refusal and truancy are distinct but not mutually exclusive and are significantly associated with psychopathology as well as adverse experiences at home and school.

Prognosis

School refusal often spontaneously resolves with age, dissipating harmlessly without any residual dysfunction. Thus, generally, the prognosis is positive. However, it can also harken imminent psychological perturbations. 

Complications

Missing significant periods of schooling can lead to maturational delays, both cognitively, psychologically, and socially. Additionally, if school refusal is not simply an isolated symptom but rather a feature of a constellation of a more serious illness, more serious sequelae can ensue.