Rule of Nines

Function

The Rule of Nines assesses the proportion of body surface area with partial- and full-thickness burns. Partial-thickness burns affect the epidermis and the papillary or reticular dermis or both layers. These patients present with painful burns, unroofed or intact blisters, and either a homogenous pink/red wound bed if superficial or a slightly mottled wound bed if deeper. Full-thickness burns extend beyond the dermis, are often insensate, and have a charred or leather-like appearance.[2] Once the TBSA is determined and the patient is weighed in kilograms, the amount of fluid resuscitation is calculated using several formulas if the adult patient has more than 20% TBSA.

Fluid resuscitation is paramount as the injured skin allows for insensible losses, and vascular permeability increases, which causes fluid to migrate into interstitial space.[10] The most commonly used formulas include the Parkland and the modified Brooke formula. The Parkland formula was developed in 1968 by Baxter and Shire and calculates the 24-hour resuscitation requirements for large TBSA using 4 mL of crystalloid intravenous fluids per kilogram of body weight per TBSA percent burned. Due to concerns of over-resuscitation, the modified Brooke formula emerged to assist in eliminating the consequences in multiple organ systems associated with excess fluid administration. The modified Brooke formula uses 2 mL of crystalloid instead of the 4 mL described in the Parkland formula.[11]

After the total volume of intravenous fluid resuscitation for the first 24 hours is established, the first half of the volume is given over the first 8 hours, and the remainder is administered over the next 16 hours. The hourly fluid rate is determined by dividing half the total volume by 8 and 16 hours, respectively. The marked start time of fluid resuscitation begins at the time of the burn injury. Should the patient present 2 hours after sustaining the burn and intravenous fluid resuscitation has not been started, the first half of the volume should be given in the next 6 hours. However, if intravenous fluids were administered before arrival, this amount of fluid should be accounted for in the total amount of fluids required.

Colloids are not recommended during the first 8 hours after burn injury as the damage to the endothelial barrier does not limit intravascular fluid losses. Ultimately, the use of colloids can reduce resuscitative volumes and limit over-resuscitation.[12] Resuscitative fluids should be titrated to maintain a goal urine output greater than 0.5 mL per kilogram per hour (30 mL per hour) for adults and children over 30 kg and greater than 1 mL per kilogram of body weight per hour in children below 30 kg.[12][13] Proper fluid resuscitation is key in determining a patient's mortality and risk of complications during the acute initial phase of injury. An unbalanced resuscitation places the patient at risk for developing end-organ damage if the patient is under-resuscitated or pulmonary edema and abdominal compartment syndrome with over-resuscitation.[1][14][15] 

Issues of Concern

There is a concern among clinicians about the accuracy of the Rule of Nines given the varying nature of provider subjectivity, especially for assessments within larger body regions.[16] This concept becomes more problematic when determining TBSA in obese and pediatric populations. The discrepancy in TBSA becomes even more apparent when calculated by less experienced providers.[8] The shortcoming of TBSA assessment is not a novel concept and has been well-documented since the 1980s.[17] 

Nevertheless, the Rule of Nines provides the most accurate estimations of TBSA patients greater than 10 kg and less than 80 kg. Unfortunately, the Rule of Nines assumes all adults have the same distribution of body surface area percentages regardless of their varying weight, height, and body shapes.[1][18] A patient's BMI is internationally recognized as the most commonly used criterion for defining obesity.[10] For obese and pediatric patients, special consideration should be taken.

Obese Patients 

• The obesity epidemic is ongoing in the United States, with rates increasing from 2-fold up to 7-fold and continuing to rise.
• Patients defined as obese by BMI, with a BMI over 30, have disproportionately larger trunks than their nonobese counterparts.
• Obese patients have a closer approximation to 50% TBSA of the trunk, 15% TBSA for each leg, 7% TBSA for each arm, and 6% TBSA for the head.
• Android-shaped patients, defined as a preferential trunk and upper body distribution of adipose tissue (abdomen, chest, shoulders, and the nape of the neck), have a torso closer to 53% TBSA.
• Gynecoid-shaped patients, defined as a preferential lower body distribution of adipose tissue (lower abdomen, pelvis, and thighs), have a torso closer to 48% TBSA.
• Burns on the extremities are significantly overestimated compared to burns on the torso in this population.
• The "Rule of Fives" has been proposed by Livingston et al. to overcome the inaccuracies of estimating TBSA in obese patients, given that more than 50% of TBSA is contributed by the trunk. This formula assigns each arm 5% TBSA, each leg 20%, and 50% for the trunk.  
• TBSA may be underestimated in women with larger breasts with burns to the anterior torso. For every increase in breast cup size, there is a subsequent increase by a factor of 0.1 compared to the posterior torso.
• Increasing weight has been associated with lower fluid resuscitation and higher mortality rates.[1][10][19][20]

Pediatric Patients

• Pediatric physiology differs from adults with smaller circulating blood volumes, greater surface area to mass ratio, thinner skin, and different body proportions throughout the various age groups. 
• Infants and younger children have proportionately larger heads, altering the surface area distribution of other major body segments. 
• The Lund and Browder paradigm accounts for the varying proportions during human growth, which allows for more accurate TBSA calculation in children. 
• A "Rule of Eights" has been proposed as a better TBSA estimate for patients weighing less than 10 kg. This rule dictates approximately 32% TBSA for the patient's trunk, 20% TBSA for the head, 16% TBSA for each leg, and 8% TBSA for each arm.[20][21][20][22]

Despite the efficiency of the Rule of Nines and its penetrance into the surgical and emergency medicine specialties, studies show that at 25% TBSA, 30% TBSA, and 35% TBSA, the percentage TBSA is overestimated by 20% when compared with computer-based applications. Overestimation of TBSA burned can lead to excessive intravenous fluid resuscitation giving the potential for volume overload and pulmonary edema with more cardiac demand. These effects can be further exacerbated if fluid resuscitation is strictly determined using the resuscitation formulas without considering the patient's individual and burn characteristics.[17] 

Patients with pre-existing comorbidities are at risk for acute cardiac and respiratory decompensation and should be monitored in the intensive care unit (ICU) during the aggressive fluid resuscitation phase, preferably in a burn center.[23][24] Burns can also convert to deeper or more widespread burns as time progresses, which can alter the TBSA estimation.[25]

Clinical Significance

The Rule of Nines is a simple and time-efficient tool used to determine the initial management of resuscitation in larger burned patients. Once the patient's clothing is removed, their TBSA percentage can be defined in a few minutes with the proper resources. On the other hand, the Rule of Palms can be more beneficial in smaller burns. The affected areas are measured using the patient's palm with fingers adducted, which is advertised to be 1% TBSA. However, this method can also lead to a 10% to 20% overestimation because the surface areas of the palm with fingers are proportionally smaller, with 0.8% TBSA in men and 0.7% in women.[18] 

Proper TBSA calculation will also assist healthcare providers in determining if the patient's burns meet the criteria for transfer to a burn center. Other transfer criteria include burns to the face, genitals, and hands, among other defined criteria by the American Burn Association.[2] Increased volume of burn referrals from single institutions and specific adult ages have not been shown to improve accuracies in determining TBSA.[26]

Other Issues

Human error is inevitable in all aspects of medicine, especially when evaluating burn depth and size. Computer-based smartphone applications are being produced to assist in minimizing errors with overestimating and underestimating TBSA percentages. The applications utilize male and female models of standardized small, average, and obese sizes. This modern technology has revealed the variability in reporting TBSA percentages, with up to 60% overestimation and 70% underestimation of the burned surface area.[2][16] Even though not every technological advance is available at all institutions, mobile applications can be used as triaging tools to assist in decision-making and disposition.[16]

Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes

The Rule of Nines is a tool healthcare professionals use to assess the total body surface area involved in burn patients. The healthcare team's initial burn surface area measurement is essential in estimating fluid resuscitation requirements. Patients should have resuscitation started promptly due to the massive fluid losses and transferred to the nearest burn center. However, due to evaluator subjectivity, the measurement of TBSA varies. Thus, frequent healthcare provider education training on calculating TBSA and determining burn depths should be performed by certified and experienced burn providers to ensure that adequate standard of care practices are upheld within the community. Moreover, patient care can be improved by referring facilities and sending pictures of the injuries to the burn attending on call to facilitate proper management and triage. Numerous studies have demonstrated the success and economic benefits of telemedicine.[25]