Calcaneofibular Ligament Injury

Etiology

Sports activities account for a large percentage of lateral ankle injuries. Specifically, indoor and court sports sustain the highest risk for an ankle injury.[4]

Epidemiology

Isolated CFL injuries are rare as reported incidences are commonly classified under lateral ligament injuries. Thirty thousand ankle sprains occur each day, accounting for 25% to 40% of sports injuries. The lateral ligament compartment is involved in 85% of ankle injuries, with a daily incidence of one in 10,000.[1][5][6]

Pathophysiology

The CFL measures approximately 20 mm long with a diameter of 6 to 8 mm, originating at the anterior lateral malleolus and attaching to the posterior lateral tubercle of the calcaneus.[3] The fibularis brevis and longus tendons and their sheaths cross over the CFL ligament. The CFL is reinforced by either the lateral talocalcaneal ligament or anterior talocalcaneal ligament, in 35% and 42% of cases, respectively.[7] The CFL resists inversion in both plantarflexion and dorsiflexion and stabilizes the subtalar joint during plantarflexion. While combined inversion and supination is the mechanism of injury to the lateral ankle, an isolated CFL injury occurs from inversion in extreme dorsiflexion.[3][6] The CFL can sustain a loading force of 109 plus or minus 28 N, and while working with ATFL stretch during high-grade ankle sprains, it can withstand a force of 345 N.[1]

History and Physical

History and physical examination are important in triaging injuries for proper interventions. Patients may endorse cracking sound, swelling, redness, pain, and cessation of activities. As such, physical examination should focus on inspection, palpation, and special maneuvers such as anterior drawer test, and talar tilt test.[8] The anterior drawer test involves a patient with the foot in a neutral position while the examiner places anterior force onto the ankle. Laxity of the injured ankle in comparison to the unaffected foot is positive for anterior drawer test.[9] Similarly, the talar tilt test can be performed with the patient’s foot in a neutral position as the examiner exerts a tilting force to invert the ankle. The injured ankle is compared to the unaffected side for laxity. [10] As such, the anterior drawer and talar tilt test can be subjective.  Following the initial assessment, physical findings of ecchymosis with localized pain on palpation 4 to 5 days post-trauma carry a 90% chance of lateral ligament rupture.[8] Patients with tenderness to palpation over the CFL have a 72% risk of ligament injury.[3] The Ottawa ankle rule on initial assessment for radiographic stewardship utilizes palpation of four locations of pain (posterior edge or tip of either malleolus, navicular bone, or base of fifth metatarsal bone) and the ability to bear weight. This assessment tool has a sensitivity of 96.4% to 99.6%, which makes it valuable in excluding ankle fractures.[11]

Evaluation

Patients with positive findings on the Ottawa ankle test should be referred for X-ray of the ankle.  It is important to note that the prevalence of ankle fractures occur in less than 15% of cases.[11] Ultrasonography offers an advantage with dynamic imaging, and MRI can be implemented in cases with high suspicion for ligament injury. The accuracy of ultrasound is dependent on the technique and expertise of the clinician. It has a sensitivity and specificity of (92%) and (64 %) for detecting ligamentous injury.[8] Given high clinical suspicion for fracture, clinicians can implement MRI as this imaging modality has high sensitivity (93% to 96%) and specificity (100%).[12]

Following physical examination, lateral ankle injury is classified into three grades: 

1. Grade I injuries are due to the stretching of the ligament.
2. Grade II is a moderate sprain.
3. Grade III involves severe sprain full ligament lesions.

The increased grade indicates the severity of the injury, and as such, each grade assists clinicians with appropriate treatment, prognosis, and anticipated complications.[8]

Treatment / Management

Conservative management is often effective in treating CFL injuries. The progression of healing following initial injury has three distinct phases: inflammatory (1 to 10 days), proliferative (4 to 8 weeks), and remodeling phase (up to one year).[13] As such, each biological phase offers a unique therapeutic window for intervention.(A1)

During the initial inflammatory response, RICE (rest, ice, compression, and elevation) is implemented in the first 4 to 5 days. Immobilization with cast or boots can be applied in the first week to reduce swelling and pain, after which, brace or taping can be provided for a return to activity.[8] Immobilization during the proliferative stage is not encouraged since functional stress helps to promote remodeling. Ankle support with semi-rigid ankle brace is used for grade I to II injuries, while a cast immobilization followed by a semi-rigid orthosis can be used for grade III.[13] Over the counter, oral agents such as NSAIDs can be used to assist with pain.(A1)

Most lateral ankle injuries are managed non-operatively, while surgical interventions are allocated to patients with chronic instability.[8] Rigby et al. described two cases of isolated calcaneofibular ligament injury with one undergoing surgical intervention while another patient had conservative management with immobilization and physical therapy. Both patients had optimal outcomes. Surgical intervention must be analyzed on an individualized base, and in some patients, surgery can decrease recurrence rate and ankle instability; however, the overall clinical outcome is similar in conservative vs. surgical intervention.[8][13](A1)

Differential Diagnosis

CFL injury often involves the ATFL, and as such, isolated ATFL should be considered on the differential. Importantly, other differentials to consider are osteochondral injury, fibularis tendon injury, ankle fractures, Achilles rupture, and tendon dislocation. Lastly, injuries of the subtalar joint should be considered as CFL injuries can involve this joint.[14]

Prognosis

Return to play or work is an important discussion at the time of diagnosis, given that 25% of patients are expected to miss school or work.[15] Much more, patients may experience long term instability or pain. Four years after inciting injury, approximately 74% of patients continue to experience chronic symptoms of either pain, swelling, weakness, or instability. Additionally, 32% of patients have reported symptoms up to 7 years from the original injury.[15] A systematic review by Thompson et al. found that characteristics such as pain intensity, weight-bearing status, and range of motion to be an inconsistent prognostic factor due to bias with individual studies. However, these clinical findings can be used with caution to assist patients with anticipated recovery.

Complications

Lateral ankle injuries are not a sentinel event but have long term sequelae. Reinjury of the lateral compartment is a common occurrence in low-grade ankle sprains.[16] Patients can experience instability and pain which inhibits functional mobility. Chronic joint instability can progress to post-traumatic ankle joint osteoarthritis.[4]