Argyll Robertson Pupil

Article Author:
Sarah Dichter
Article Editor:
Greggory Shubert
Updated:
12/29/2018 7:23:25 PM
PubMed Link:
Argyll Robertson Pupil

Introduction

Argyll Robertson pupil describes the physical exam finding of small bilateral pupils that do not constrict when exposed to bright light but do constrict when focused on a nearby object. This finding is highly specific for late-stage syphilis. Argyll Robertson (AR) pupil was first described by Scottish ophthalmologist and surgeon, Dr. Douglas Argyll Robertson in the mid-1860s.[1]

Etiology

Argyll Robertson pupil is found in late-stage syphilis, a disease caused by the spirochete Treponema pallidum. Neurosyphilis occurs due to an invasion of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) by the spirochete which likely occurs soon after the initial acquisition of the disease. The exact pathophysiology leading to the AR pupil, however, remains unknown.

Epidemiology

The exam finding of Argyll Robertson pupils has been rare in the developed world since the advent of penicillin in the 1940s. However, in the modern era, the number of cases of primary and secondary syphilis have been increasing every year since 2001, and continue to rise. According to the CDC: there were 30,676 cases of late and late latent cases of neurosyphilis reported in the United States in 2016. The CDC acknowledges, however, that the disease is likely under-reported. From 2000 to 2016, the rise in reported syphilis cases is primarily due to increased cases in the men who have sex with men population. This may be due to the fact that syphilis is more common in MSM, many of whom concurrently also have HIV, or it could reflect two separate groups with an increased susceptibility. There is a high rate of co-infection with HIV in those MSM patients who have contracted syphilis. The US CDC data estimates that 5% of MSM with syphilis are also infected with HIV. Additionally globally, reports have indicated that syphilis has been on the rise in conjunction with the global HIV/AIDs epidemic. [2]

Pathophysiology

The exact pathophysiology of AR pupil remains unknown. The current leading theory, proposed by Thompson and Kardon (2006) is that syphilis leads to a "dorsal midbrain lesion that interrupts the pupillary light reflex pathway but spares the more ventral pupillary near the reflex pathway."

Their research implicates a portion of the rostral midbrain (brainstem) located near the Sylvian aqueduct as the most likely location of the syphilitic lesion. Damage to this area would affect the efferent pupillary fibers located on the dorsal aspect of the Edinger-Westphal nucleus (EWN), which are a part of the light reflex while sparing the fibers associated with the accommodation reflex which lay more ventrally to the EWN.[3][4]

History and Physical

The patient with AR pupil will show small, irregular pupils with light-near dissociation: absent light reflex, prompt constriction with near accommodation. Symptoms are usually bilateral and have a gradual onset of months to years. The pupils will initially have a sluggish response to light, progressing eventually to a complete absence of the light reflex. Close examination may show an atrophied iris with loss of the radial folds and crypts. Additionally, pupils will exhibit slow dilation with atropine (or other mydriatics).

Other findings to correlate the diagnosis of AR pupil are those suggestive of late-stage syphilis, such as:

  • Tabes dorsalis: The posterior columns of the spinal cord and its dorsal root become affected in this stage of syphilis.
  • These patients suffer from sensory ataxia – lack of coordination due to a loss of sensory input into the control of movement (not from cerebellar pathology) and lancinating pains – the sensation of sudden, brief, severe pains over the face, back, limbs that can last from minutes to days.
  • Those patients afflicted with tabes dorsalis often have pupil irregularities, 50% of which will be the distinctive AR pupil.[5]

Evaluation

Various tests can diagnose syphilis.

The gold standard remains visualization of spirochetes on dark field microscopy. More commonly, however, non-treponemal blood work for VRDL (venereal disease research laboratory) or RPR (rapid plasma reagin) is sent to rule in the disease, and then confirmatory testing assessing for FTA-ABS (fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption), TPPA (Treponema pallidum particle agglutination assay) or EIAs (syphilis enzyme immunoassays) is obtained.

A lumbar puncture can be useful in the diagnosis of neurosyphilis in a patient with an unknown syphilis history who is presenting with neurologic and ocular disease that could be consistent with the disease. Lumbar puncture is required in the evaluation of a patient with known syphilis presenting with these same symptoms. Furthermore, a lumbar puncture is suggested in all HIV patients with syphilis regardless of their presenting symptoms.

CSF findings indicative of neurosyphilis will show greater than 20 WBC/uL, and return positive for VRDL and intrathecal pallidum antibody index.[6]

Treatment / Management

There is no treatment for AR pupil, however; the progression can be controlled with the treatment of the underlying disease, syphilis. Treatment is with penicillin G benzathine (124 Mu intramuscularly [IM]). Alternatively, doxycycline (100 mg orally [PO]) can be used for those with a penicillin allergy.[7]

Differential Diagnosis

Several other conditions may present similarly to AR pupils, as they also demonstrate a light near dislocation.

Either input or output failures can cause light-near dissociation. Bilateral pre-chiasmal lesions of the optic nerves, chiasmal lesions or bilateral optic tract lesions could cause input failure, leading to a false light-near dissociation: The light reflex will be reduced under these conditions, and the near reaction unaffected. Output failure is the cause of AR pupil, as well as Adie’s pupil, the Miller-Fisher variant of acute idiopathic demyelinating polyradiculopathy, and in the setting of uncontrolled diabetes mellitus and certain peripheral neuropathies. AR pupil can de be differentiated from these other conditions by the pupillary size: Argyll Robertson pupil alone presents with small pupils, the other diagnoses all demonstrate large light-dissociated pupils.[8]

Prognosis

The presence of AR pupils carries a significant implication, neurosyphilis. This is a disease with multi-organ impact and carries high morbidity. Once AR pupils have been diagnosed, patients should begin immediate and potent treatment to eliminate the infection and halt the progression of the disease. The sooner the diagnosis is made and acted upon, the better the prognosis for the patient.

Complications

AR pupils are found in the tertiary and final stage of infection with syphilis. These patients are afflicted with neurologic and cardiovascular disease. Such complications include an aortic aneurysm and insufficiency of the aortic valve, meningitis, and tabetic disease. While treatment can arrest the progression of the disease, the resolution of symptoms is dependent on the extent of the underlying disease. For those with cardiac or nerve involvement, the damage is not reversible, and these patients carry the poorest prognosis.[9]

Deterrence and Patient Education

Prevention of the disease is through primary prevention. There is no vaccination for syphilis. Sexual education is recommended to prevent the transmission of syphilis.

Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes

Patients with AR pupils, implicating a late-stage syphilis infection can require a team of health-care professionals to aid in their treatment and recovery. An infectious disease specialist should be consulted for the underlying infection or co-infections, and consultation with ophthalmology. Patients may require cardiology and neurology depending on the extent and a breadth of other symptoms. Patients should be educated on safe sex practice to prevent transmission and re-infection.



  • (Move Mouse on Image to Enlarge)
    • Image 7288 Not availableImage 7288 Not available
      Image courtesy S Bhimji MD

References

[1] Robertson DA, Four Cases of Spinal Myosis; with Remarks on the Action of Light on the Pupil. Edinburgh medical journal. 1869 Dec     [PubMed PMID: 29638473]
[2] Golden MR,Marra CM,Holmes KK, Update on syphilis: resurgence of an old problem. JAMA. 2003 Sep 17     [PubMed PMID: 13129993]
[3] Thompson HS,Kardon RH, The Argyll Robertson pupil. Journal of neuro-ophthalmology : the official journal of the North American Neuro-Ophthalmology Society. 2006 Jun     [PubMed PMID: 16845316]
[4]     [PubMed PMID: 15314131]
[5]     [PubMed PMID: 12189266]
[6]     [PubMed PMID: 30366549]
[7]     [PubMed PMID: 30102654]
[8]     [PubMed PMID: 6472802]
[9]     [PubMed PMID: 20864080]