Adult acquired flatfoot (AAFD), first described as posterior tibial tendon dysfunction (PTTD), is a complex pathology defined by the collapse of the medial longitudinal arch of the foot with continued progressive deformity of the foot and ankle. Adult acquired flatfoot is a debilitating condition that affects up to 5 million people within the US.
The anatomy of the foot and ankle are complex, with multiple structures involved in the stability and function needed to walk and bear weight. A structure principally involved in the development of adult acquired flatfoot is the posterior tibial tendon. In addition to plantar flexion, the posterior tibial tendon is the primary inverter of the foot. The posterior tibial tendon inserts principally on the navicular tuberosity, but also has lesser insertions on to other tarsal and metatarsal structures. The spring and deltoid ligaments are crucial to the stability of the foot and ankle. The spring ligament, which is the ligament most frequently involved in adult acquired flatfoot, supports the ankle by connections from the sustentaculum tali of the calcaneus to the navicular. The primary role of the spring ligament is to support the head of the talus. The deltoid ligament is usually affected later in the progression of adult acquired flatfoot. The superficial deltoid ligament has a wide insertion on the navicular to the posterior tibiotalar capsule. It is the primary support against tibiotalar valgus angulation. The deep deltoid ligament prevents axial rotation of the talus, where it inserts, from its origin on the intercollicular groove and posterior colliculus. The deltoid ligament as a whole is critical in supporting the articulating surfaces of the ankle and the spring ligament.
Acquired flatfoot grading is by the Johnson and Strom classification system, which has classification grades of I to III. Myerson added a fourth grade in 1997. The classification system aids practitioners in identifying AAFD severity and also can guide treatment plans. Stage I disease characteristically presents with posterior tibial tendon tenosynovitis with no arch collapse. Patients with stage II adult acquired flatfoot will have foot collapse and will be unable to perform a single leg heel rise. This stage further subcategorizes into stage IIa and IIb. Stage IIa is foot collapse with valgus deformity of the hindfoot but no midfoot abduction, while in stage IIb midfoot abduction is present. Patients with stage III adult acquired flatfoot will have fixed deformity with hindfoot valgus and forefoot abduction. Patients with stage IV deformity will have ankle valgus secondary to deltoid ligament attenuation.
Acquired flatfoot was historically attributed to posterior tibial tendon deficiency, although now the understanding is that the ligamentous structures of the ankle play a role in adult acquired flatfoot development. Dysfunction of the posterior tibial tendon is a multifactorial process. In many patients, there is a preexisting flatfoot, and many patients are also obese. Another factor is a relative hypovascularity of the tendon as it makes an abrupt turn posterior to the medial malleolus; this predisposes the tendon to rupture due to insufficient repair. Episodes of previous trauma, corticosteroid injections, arthritis, neuromuscular conditions, and diabetes all predispose to the development of adult acquired flatfoot.
Acquired flatfoot is a common orthopedic condition, although there is a relative paucity of literature on the epidemiology regarding adult acquired flatfoot. There are 5 million people in the United States affected with adult acquired flatfoot. In the UK, the estimated prevalence is estimated to be over 3% in women over 40 years old. Posterior tibial tendon issues are prevalent in the geriatric population, with 10% of geriatric patients affected. Ikpeze et al. postulated that the geriatric population might be predisposed to more severe adult acquired flatfoot due to degeneration of muscle mass and bone structure, as well. Patients with chronic vascular diseases are at increased risk; this includes diabetics and patients with hypertension.
The posterior tibial tendon is critical in maintaining appropriate gait and function of the foot. Contraction of the tibialis posterior causes the inversion of the foot and locking of the transverse tarsal joints granting stability for push-off. Deficiency of the posterior tibial tendon leads to an unstable transverse tarsal joint and forefoot abduction, allowing unopposed action of the peroneus brevis. The ensuing abduction of the forefoot and transverse talar joints also displace the force of the calcaneal tendon laterally, further accentuating the valgus defect of the foot. The continued strain on the static stabilizing ligaments eventually leads to their attenuation. Most commonly, the spring ligament is affected, failure leads to medial and plantar subluxation of the talar head relative to the navicular. Failure of the deltoid ligament will lead to a valgus position of the talus within the ankle mortise. These events may occur in a stepwise fashion, corresponding to Johnson and Strom classification system. However, some patients develop a valgus talar tilt without a fixed flatfoot deformity.
It is essential to evaluate the patient with suspected adult acquired flatfoot during weight bearing. There are specific hallmark findings of adult acquired flatfoot that for which practitioners should look. While the patient is standing with the provider behind excessive abduction of the forefoot can be noted by the “too many toes” sign. This test is positive if the practitioner can see more than the fifth and part of the fourth toe. Inspection and palpation over the posterior tibial tendon at the area of the medial malleolus may demonstrate swelling or pain. On the lateral aspect of the foot pain may be elicited if there is impingement of ligamentous structures. Single and double heel rise tests may be performed to assess the strength of the posterior tibial tendon. Failure to invert the foot on heel rise or perform heel rise at all is considered indicative of posterior tibial tendon dysfunction. Ankle range of motion requires assessment. Effort should be made to correct valgus deformity in a range of motion exercise to evaluate for fixed deformity. A fixed deformity of the subtalar joint or fixed abduction of the forefoot have implications in treatment.
The gold standard for the evaluation of adult acquired flatfoot is weight-bearing radiographs. Radiographs are necessary in the anteroposterior, lateral, and hindfoot views. These views will assess the degree of arch collapse, particularly by measuring the lateral first tarsometatarsal angle, and forefoot abduction at the talonavicular joint. Talar head uncoverage can also be measured in the setting of stage IV disease by the lateral talonavicular angle. Lateral views of the foot can also display naviculocuneiform and first tarsometatarsal collapse. Arthritis should be carefully assessed for on all radiographic films as this may have implications on treatment options.
MRI is typically not needed for evaluation of adult acquired flatfoot; however, it may be beneficial for some patients with ligamentous involvement that may alter surgical treatment planning; this is particularly relevant for patients with medial peritalar instability, who have improved functional outcomes with deltoid-spring ligament reconstruction.
Several studies indicate that ultrasound may be a useful modality in assessing the posterior tibial tendon when compared to the more time consuming and costly MRI. Results from an ultrasonographic evaluation of the posterior tibial tendon were equivalent to MRI in 87% to 94% of patients.
Treatment of adult acquired flatfoot is complex. There are multiple treatment options, and the treatment of adult acquired flatfoot has been the focus of most recent research. However, the first line therapy for the condition remains nonoperative.
Treatment with orthotic devices, such as low-articulating ankle-foot orthosis, cast-boot walkers, and other ankle-foot orthoses in conjunction with NSAID therapy and physical therapy have a resolution of symptoms 87% of the time according to one study. Other studies have success rates of 67 to 90% with conservative measures.
Surgical treatment is indicated in patients who have attempted conservative therapy and are not satisfied with their results. Surgical treatment depends on the stage of the disease, as well as other factors including medical comorbidities, functional status, and use of tobacco.
Surgical management of stage I disease is uncommon, but if required patients should undergo posterior tibial tendon tenosynovectomy, debridement, or flexor digitorum longus tendon autograft. There is a concern that repair of the posterior tibial tendon may experience complications with long-term failure; therefore, surgical treatment should be carefully considered prior to any intervention.
Stage II disease treatment has been successful by medializing calcaneal osteotomy in addition to a flexor digitorum longus transfer. One study showed 87% patient satisfaction with this treatment after a mean follow-up of 15 years.
Stage III disease becomes more challenging to treat due to the fixed nature of the defect. Arthrodesis is the standard of care, with double and triple arthrodesis being common. Double arthrodesis entails fusion of the subtalar and talonavicular joints. Triple arthrodesis involves the calcaneocuboid joint in addition to the two joints mentioned above. Double arthrodesis has the advantage of reduced arthritic complications and reduced joint stiffness associated with calcaneocuboid fusion. Unfortunately, joint fusion has an inherent loss of mobility, and patients may struggle on uneven ground. Risk of nonunion, deltoid insufficiency, and ankle valgus is also present.
Stage IV disease management depends on whether there is a rigid flatfoot. Some patients progress to stage IV disease without rigid disease due to failure of the deltoid ligament. In this setting, patients may have treatment with a deltoid ligament repair. Patients with rigid stage IV disease will require an ankle fusion, which is associated with significant morbidity. Ankle replacement is an alternative to arthrodesis.
A recent meta-analysis of surgical treatments for adult acquired flatfoot was conducted to study the efficacy of different therapies further. This study analyzed different radiographic angles to measure the effectiveness of each procedure, including medial calcaneal osteotomies, lateral column lengthening, and double and triple arthrodesis. The conclusions of the study suggested that all treatment types result in significant improvements for the patient.
While the diagnosis of adult acquired flatfoot is relatively straightforward, there are several diagnoses that a provider needs to rule out when acquired flatfoot is suspected. These include adult flexible flatfoot, tarsal coalition, Charcot foot, neuromuscular flatfoot, and arthritic, post-traumatic, and iatrogenic deformity. A careful history and physical can rule out most of these etiologies.
The prognosis for most patients with adult acquired flatfoot is favorable. Most patients will not need surgery. The approximately 10% that do require surgery can expect favorable outcomes. The higher stage diseases require more extensive surgery, with stage IV adult acquired flatfoot requiring ankle fusion or total ankle arthroplasty.
Adult acquired flatfoot that is left untreated can progress to more severe stages that require more invasive treatments. Early diagnosis is critical and can even help avoid surgery in some patients. As the disease progresses into late stages, the need for the patient to get an ankle fusion increases. With an ankle fusion, the patient essentially has an immobile ankle joint, and many recreational activities are affected.
Acquired flatfoot appears to be associated with obesity, diabetes, hypertension, and other disease processes that are treatable with a healthy lifestyle and weight reduction. Patients with adult acquired flatfoot may benefit from treatment of their other medical comorbidities. Additionally, patients may prevent further disease progression once diagnosed by use of an appropriate orthotic device. Most patients who use an orthotic device in conjunction with PT and or NSAID therapy will not need any surgical intervention.
Acquired flatfoot is a common disease that when recognized early, is highly treatable with excellent outcomes. All members of the healthcare team can play a role in the identification, treatment, and follow-up of care for patients with acquired flatfoot. This team may consist of family practitioners, specialty-trained nurses, orthopedic and foot and ankle surgeons, physical therapists, radiologists, and orthotists. As with all orthopedic surgery, a physical therapist must work closely with surgeons to assure adequate recovery and slow progression to full activity. Family practitioners may be the first physicians to see the patient and diagnose the disorder. They should be aware of the basic diagnostic criteria and treatment protocols so that patients can be referred to surgeons when non-operative management is futile.
|||Deland JT, Adult-acquired flatfoot deformity. The Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. 2008 Jul; [PubMed PMID: 18611997]|
|||Hadfield MH,Snyder JW,Liacouras PC,Owen JR,Wayne JS,Adelaar RS, Effects of medializing calcaneal osteotomy on Achilles tendon lengthening and plantar foot pressures. Foot [PubMed PMID: 12921356]|
|||Abousayed MM,Alley MC,Shakked R,Rosenbaum AJ, Adult-Acquired Flatfoot Deformity: Etiology, Diagnosis, and Management. JBJS reviews. 2017 Aug; [PubMed PMID: 28806265]|
|||Bastias GF,Dalmau-Pastor M,Astudillo C,Pellegrini MJ, Spring Ligament Instability. Foot and ankle clinics. 2018 Dec; [PubMed PMID: 30414659]|
|||Smith JT,Bluman EM, Update on stage IV acquired adult flatfoot disorder: when the deltoid ligament becomes dysfunctional. Foot and ankle clinics. 2012 Jun; [PubMed PMID: 22541531]|
|||Johnson KA,Strom DE, Tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction. Clinical orthopaedics and related research. 1989 Feb; [PubMed PMID: 2912622]|
|||Myerson MS, Adult acquired flatfoot deformity: treatment of dysfunction of the posterior tibial tendon. Instructional course lectures. 1997; [PubMed PMID: 9143981]|
|||Abousayed MM,Tartaglione JP,Rosenbaum AJ,Dipreta JA, Classifications in Brief: Johnson and Strom Classification of Adult-acquired Flatfoot Deformity. Clinical orthopaedics and related research. 2016 Feb; [PubMed PMID: 26472584]|
|||Smyth NA,Aiyer AA,Kaplan JR,Carmody CA,Kadakia AR, Adult-acquired flatfoot deformity. European journal of orthopaedic surgery [PubMed PMID: 28324203]|
|||Petersen W,Hohmann G,Stein V,Tillmann B, The blood supply of the posterior tibial tendon. The Journal of bone and joint surgery. British volume. 2002 Jan; [PubMed PMID: 11837820]|
|||Holmes GB Jr,Mann RA, Possible epidemiological factors associated with rupture of the posterior tibial tendon. Foot [PubMed PMID: 1349292]|
|||Kohls-Gatzoulis J,Woods B,Angel JC,Singh D, The prevalence of symptomatic posterior tibialis tendon dysfunction in women over the age of 40 in England. Foot and ankle surgery : official journal of the European Society of Foot and Ankle Surgeons. 2009; [PubMed PMID: 19410173]|
|||Ikpeze TC,Brodell JD Jr,Chen RE,Oh I, Evaluation and Treatment of Posterior Tibialis Tendon Insufficiency in the Elderly Patients. Geriatric orthopaedic surgery [PubMed PMID: 30719400]|
|||Brodsky JW, Preliminary gait analysis results after posterior tibial tendon reconstruction: a prospective study. Foot [PubMed PMID: 14992709]|
|||Vulcano E,Deland JT,Ellis SJ, Approach and treatment of the adult acquired flatfoot deformity. Current reviews in musculoskeletal medicine. 2013 Dec; [PubMed PMID: 23765382]|
|||Brodell JD Jr,MacDonald A,Perkins JA,Deland JT,Oh I, Deltoid-Spring Ligament Reconstruction in Adult Acquired Flatfoot Deformity With Medial Peritalar Instability. Foot [PubMed PMID: 30902021]|
|||Arnoldner MA,Gruber M,Syré S,Kristen KH,Trnka HJ,Kainberger F,Bodner G, Imaging of posterior tibial tendon dysfunction--Comparison of high-resolution ultrasound and 3T MRI. European journal of radiology. 2015 Sep; [PubMed PMID: 26037267]|
|||Harish S,Kumbhare D,O'Neill J,Popowich T, Comparison of sonography and magnetic resonance imaging for spring ligament abnormalities: preliminary study. Journal of ultrasound in medicine : official journal of the American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine. 2008 Aug; [PubMed PMID: 18645072]|
|||Chadwick C,Whitehouse SL,Saxby TS, Long-term follow-up of flexor digitorum longus transfer and calcaneal osteotomy for stage II posterior tibial tendon dysfunction. The bone [PubMed PMID: 25737518]|
|||Ketz J,Myerson M,Sanders R, The salvage of complex hindfoot problems with use of a custom talar total ankle prosthesis. The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume. 2012 Jul 3; [PubMed PMID: 22760387]|
|||Tao X,Chen W,Tang K, Surgical procedures for treatment of adult acquired flatfoot deformity: a network meta-analysis. Journal of orthopaedic surgery and research. 2019 Feb 21; [PubMed PMID: 30791933]|
|||Lee MS,Vanore JV,Thomas JL,Catanzariti AR,Kogler G,Kravitz SR,Miller SJ,Gassen SC, Diagnosis and treatment of adult flatfoot. The Journal of foot and ankle surgery : official publication of the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons. 2005 Mar-Apr; [PubMed PMID: 15768358]|