Clinodactyly

Article Author:
Devon Banda
Article Editor:
Amjad Yaish
Updated:
8/10/2020 9:27:10 PM
PubMed Link:
Clinodactyly

Introduction

Clinodactyly is defined as a congenital curvature of a digit distal to the metacarpal phalangeal joint in the coronal plane. Curvatures with an angular deviation of fewer than 10 degrees can be seen as a normal physiologic variant. Clinodactyly is defined when the coronal angulation of the affected digit is greater than 10 degrees. The curvature arises due to the abnormal trapezoidal or triangular shape of one or more phalanges, which leads to malalignment of the associated interphalangeal joint. This abnormal shape leads to asymmetric longitudinal growth in a direction deviated from the normal longitudinal axis of the finger resulting in the visible curvature of the digit.[1]

Etiology

Clinodactyly can occur in syndromic, familial, and sporadic forms.[2] The trait expresses autosomal dominant inheritance and most commonly involves the middle phalanx of the small finger. Several studies have also documented the involvement of the proximal phalanx of the index finger and thumb.[3] The curvature arises due to the abnormal trapezoidal or triangular shape of one or more phalanges, which leads to malalignment of the associated interphalangeal joint. This abnormal shape leads to asymmetric longitudinal growth in a direction deviated from the normal longitudinal axis of the finger resulting in the visible curvature of the digit.

Epidemiology

The incidence of clinodactyly is unknown; however, rates have been reported between 1% and 19.5%. It is often seen bilaterally, and males have been found to be more likely to express the trait. In has been associated with several syndromic anomalies, including Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome, Cenani-Lenz syndactyly, Klinefelter syndrome, Turner syndrome, Fanconi anemia and is present in up to 25% of children with Down syndrome. Clinodactyly is often present in the neonate; however, its presentation typically occurs in later childhood years as the deformity becomes more noticeable as longitudinal growth occurs. Patients present for treatment typically due to the abnormal appearance of the digit; however, the deformity rarely causes functional impairment due to compensatory abduction of the affected digit, which prevents the curvature from obstructing full digit flexion.

Pathophysiology

Longitudinal growth of the phalanges is driven from epiphyseal growth from the proximal portion of the phalanx. Abnormal configuration of the epiphyseal plate results in the curvature seen in clinodactyly. In clinodactyly, a C-shaped physis is often present and results in incomplete or restricted longitudinal growth on one side of the phalanx. In cases of early complete physeal plate ossification, no longitudinal growth will be possible, and a classic delta phalanx will be produced. The severity of the deformity can vary, and a classification system has been described.[4] Acquired cases of clinodactyly can be seen after traumatic injuries to the epiphyseal plate.[5] Cases of inflammatory and infectious arthritis can also cause longitudinal grown disturbances.[6]

History and Physical

History and physical exam will reveal the curvature of the affected digit in the radial/ulnar plane. It is essential to determine if the deformity affects the radial digits of the hand or if pinch function is compromised due to the deformity. Range of motion testing should be documented, and a complete history should reflect if the deformity is congenital or post-traumatic, stable or progressive.

Evaluation

Plain radiographs can aid in the diagnosis of clinodactyly. A radial or ulnar curvature will be present, and a shortened middle phalanx will often be seen, which is typically shorter on the radial rather than the ulnar side. A C-shaped physis or delta phalanx may also be present on plain radiographs.[7] Occasionally a prenatal ultrasound may identify clinodactyly.

Treatment / Management

The vast majority of cases can be treated conservatively with observation. Splinting of the affected digit has been found to be ineffective and is not recommended. Most presentations of isolated clinodactyly are due to aesthetic/cosmetic concerns, and functional concerns rarely arise. Surgery is for cosmetic correction is not advised due to the complications associated with surgical intervention, which include scarring and stiffness of the affected digit. Surgical intervention is reserved for severe clinodactyly with angulation and shortening, predominantly when there is the involvement of the thumb or radial digits, as severe deformities can often interfere with pinch and grasp.[1]

In cases of severe deformity that involve the radial digits or limit pinch, several different operative treatment options exist. Corrective osteotomy is the mainstay surgical treatment for correction of clinodactyly and, if possible, should be reserved until skeletal maturity is reached. Osteotomy can be challenging in the skeletally immature patient due to the risk of physeal injury, or excessive or incomplete correction. Options include opening or closing wedge osteotomy, reverse wedge osteotomy, and epiphyseal bracket resection and fat grafting. Opening wedge osteotomy requires bone grafting and allows for the preservation of length or the option to increase length; however, this requires a donor site that may be limited in a skeletally immature patient. Closing wedge osteotomy is an attractive option due to its simplicity; however, it typically results in some degree of shortening, which may be significant if the initial degree of shortening is substantial. The reverse wedge osteotomy is a technically challenging procedure when performed on a skeletally immature hand and requires access to both sides of the affected digit. In all cases of corrective osteotomy, the soft tissue deficit that is created with either lengthening or shortening of the digit must be addressed. Soft tissue deficits on the concave side can typically be treated with a "Z" -plasty. In more severe soft tissue deficits, rotational or advancement flaps may be necessary to gain adequate soft tissue coverage.[8]

In patients with open growth plates, epiphyseal bracket resection and fat grafting termed "Vicker's physiolysis" can be used as an alternative treatment option. This method of correction involves resecting the cartilaginous or osseous bracket on the short side of the affected digit and interposing in the created "dead space" with fatty tissue. After resection of the epiphyseal bracket and tissue interposition, this allows for the normal portion of the epiphyseal growth plate to generate and longitudinally correct the deformity over 1 to 2 years.[9] Results of Vicker's physiolysis, when compared with osteotomy, have been shown to be effective in patients with initial deformities less than 55 degrees and results in less revision surgery when compared to osteotomy alone.[10][11]

Differential Diagnosis

Differential diagnosis includes traumatic physeal injury, tumor, infection, and osteomyelitis. Clinodactlyly can be associated with several other medical syndromes including Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome, Cenani-Lenz syndactyly, and can be present in up to 25% of children with Down syndrome.

Prognosis

Expected outcomes following surgical intervention include the correction of the deformity.

Complications

Complications following surgical correction of deformity include stiffness, over and under correction of deformity, physeal arrest, skin deficits, and infection.[12]

Deterrence and Patient Education

In-depth discussion must be had with the patient and/or family explaining the risks and benefits of surgical intervention that must be reserved for patients with functional deficits, rather than aesthetic or cosmetic concerns. 

Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes

An interprofessional team that provides a holistic and integrated approach to diagnosis and treating patients with clinodactyly is imperative. By correctly diagnosing and recognizing surgical indications for clinodactyly, primary care physicians can help avoid the added healthcare costs of possible unnecessary testing, advanced imaging studies, and consultations. The vast majority of cases of clinodactyly can be treated with observation. When more severe cases present, it is important to consult a surgical specialist for any surgical intervention that may be indicated. 



  • Image courtesy S Bhimji MD
    (Move Mouse on Image to Enlarge)
    • Image 6547 Not availableImage 6547 Not available
      Image courtesy S Bhimji MD

References

[1] Goldfarb CA,Wall LB, Osteotomy for clinodactyly. The Journal of hand surgery. 2015 Jun;     [PubMed PMID: 25892713]
[2] Leung AK,Kao CP, Familial clinodactyly of the fifth finger. Journal of the National Medical Association. 2003 Dec;     [PubMed PMID: 14717476]
[3] Duran A,Dindar T,Bas S, Congenital Familial Clinodactyly of Index Finger with Proximal Delta Phalanges and Ulnar Deviation. Journal of hand and microsurgery. 2017 Apr;     [PubMed PMID: 28442861]
[4] Chen Y,Liu J,Zhang Z,Ding J, [Hand malformations imaging characteristics and clinical classification: a case-control study]. Zhonghua yi xue za zhi. 2015 May 19     [PubMed PMID: 26178510]
[5] Barriga-Martín A,Romero-Muñoz LM,Aquerreta-Beola D,Amillo-Garayoa S, Post-Traumatic Clinodactyly of the Little Finger in Basque Hand-Pelota Players. Revista espanola de cirugia ortopedica y traumatologia. 2020 Feb 24     [PubMed PMID: 32107140]
[6] Choo AD,Mubarak SJ, Longitudinal epiphyseal bracket. Journal of children's orthopaedics. 2013 Dec;     [PubMed PMID: 24432108]
[7] Poznanski AK,Pratt GB,Manson G,Weiss L, Clinodactyly, camptodactyly, Kirner's deformity, and other crooked fingers. Radiology. 1969 Sep;     [PubMed PMID: 5822733]
[8] Strauss NL,Goldfarb CA, Surgical correction of clinodactyly: two straightforward techniques. Techniques in hand     [PubMed PMID: 20216055]
[9] Medina JA,Lorea P,Elliot D,Foucher G, Correction of Clinodactyly by Early Physiolysis: 6-Year Results. The Journal of hand surgery. 2016 Jun;     [PubMed PMID: 26972556]
[10] Gillis JA,Nicoson MC,Floccari L,Khouri JS,Moran SL, Comparison of Vickers' Physiolysis With Osteotomy for Primary Correction of Clinodactyly. Hand (New York, N.Y.). 2019 Feb 14;     [PubMed PMID: 30762436]
[11] Lee HJ,Kim PT,Jeon IH,Deslivia MF,Lee SJ,Kim HJ,Yoon JP, Untethering physiolysis for delta phalanx (longitudinally bracketed diaphysis) combined with free fat interposition graft. Hand surgery     [PubMed PMID: 28712787]
[12] Piper SL,Goldfarb CA,Wall LB, Outcomes of opening wedge osteotomy to correct angular deformity in little finger clinodactyly. The Journal of hand surgery. 2015 May;     [PubMed PMID: 25754787]